The use of categorical regression in evidence integration

Main Article Content

Patrick J. Farrell
Peter Aggett
Brittany Milton
Siva Ramoju
Don Mattison
Nicholas Birkett
Daniel Krewski


Exposure-response assessment methods have shifted towards more quantitative approaches, with health risk assessors exploring more statistically driven techniques.  These assessments, however, usually rely on one critical health effect from a single key study.  Categorical regression addresses this limitation by incorporating data from all relevant studies – including human, animal, and mechanistic studies - thereby including a broad spectrum of health endpoints and exposure levels for exposure-response analysis in an objective manner.  Categorical regression requires the establishment of ordered response categories corresponding to increasingly severe adverse health outcomes, and the availability of a comprehensive database that summarizes all data on different outcomes from different studies, including the exposure or dose at which these outcomes are observed and their severity.  It has found application in the risk assessment of essential nutrients and trace metals.  Since adverse effects may arise from either deficient or excess exposure, the exposure-response curve is U-shaped, which provides a basis for determining optimal intake levels that minimize the joint risks of deficiency and excess. This article provides an overview of the use of categorical regression fit exposure-response models incorporating data from multiple evidence streams. An extension of categorical regression that permits the simultaneous analysis of excess and deficiency toxicity data is presented and applied to comprehensive databases on copper and manganese.  Future applications of categorical regression will be able to make greater use of diverse data sets developed using new approach methodologies, which can be expected to provide valuable information on toxic responses of varying severity.

Article Details

How to Cite
Farrell, P. J., Aggett, P., Milton, B., Ramoju, S., Mattison, D., Birkett, N. and Krewski, D. (2022) “The use of categorical regression in evidence integration”, ALTEX - Alternatives to animal experimentation. doi: 10.14573/altex.2012022.

Academy of Medical Sciences, (2007). Identifying the environmental causes of disease: how should we decide what to believe and when to take action? Available online:

Aggett, P. J. (2007). Nutrient risk assessment: Setting upper levels and an opportunity for harmonization. Food and Nutrition Bulletin, 28: S27-S37. doi:10.1177/15648265070281s104

Andersen, M. E., McMullen, P. D., Phillips, M. B., et al. (2019). Developing context appropriate toxicity testing approaches using new alternative methods (NAMs). ALTEX 36, 523-534. doi:10.14573/altex.1906261

ATSDR – Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, 2000. Toxicological Profile for Manganese (Update). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Atlanta (GA). doi:10.15620/cdc:95222

ATSDR, 2012. Toxicological Profile for Manganese. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Atlanta (GA).

Allen, B., Zeiger, E., Lawrence, G. et. al. (2005). Dose-response modeling of in vivo genotoxicity data for use in risk assessment: some approaches illustrated by an analysis of acrylamide. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 41(1), 6-27. doi:10.1016/j.yrtph.2004.09.006

Barnes, D. and Dourson, M. (1988). Reference dose (RfD): description and use in health risk assessments. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 8, 471-486. doi:10.1016/0273-2300(88)90047-5

Brown, K. G. and Foureman, G. L. (2005). Concentration-time-response modelling for acute and short-term exposures. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 43 (October 1), 45-54. doi:10.1016/j.yrtph.2005.06.002

Brown, K. G. and Strickland, J. A. (2003). Utilising data from multiple studies (meta-analysis) to determine effective dose-duration levels: example: rats and mice exposed to hydrogen sulfide. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 37 (April 2), 305-317. doi:10.1016/S0273-2300(03)00007-2

Chambers, A., Krewski, D., Birkett, N. et. al. (2010). An exposure-response curve for copper excess and deficiency. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health 13(7), 546-578. doi:10.1080/10937404.2010.538657

Chifman J. and Laubenbacher, R. 2014. A systems biology approach to iron metabolism. Adv Exp Med Biol 844, 201-225. doi:10. 1007/978-1-4939-2095-2_10

Crump, K. S. (1984). A new method for determining allowable daily intake. Fundamental and Applied Toxicology 4, 854-871. doi:10.1016/0272-0590(84)90107-6

Davies, K. J. A. (2016). Adaptive homeostasis. Molecular Aspects of Medicine 49, 1-7. doi:10.1016/j.mam.2016.04.007

Deveau, M., Chen, C. P., Johanson, G. et. al. (2015). The global landscape of occupational exposure limits-implementation of harmonization principles to guide limit selection. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene 12 (Supp. 1), S127-S144. doi:10.1080/15459624.2015.1060327

Edwards, L. M. (2017). Metabolic systems biology: a brief primer. Journal of Physiology, 2849-2855.

EFSA NDA Panel – EFSA Panel on Nutrition, Novel Foods, and Food Allergens, 2019. Scientific opinion on the dietary reference values for sodium. EFSA Journal, 17(9), 5778. doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2019.577

EFSA NDA Panel, 2022. Scientific opinion on the dietary reference values for sodium. EFSA Journal, 20(1), e200102. doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2022.e20010

Gift, J. S., McGaughty, R., Singh, D. V. and Sonawane, B. (2008). Health assessment of phosgene: approaches for the derivation of reference concentration. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 51, 98-107. doi:10.1016/j.yrtph.2008.03.004

Haber, L., Strickland, J.A. and Guth, D.J. (2001). Categorical regression analysis of toxicity data. Comments on Toxicology 7(5), 437-452.

Hartung, T. and Krewski, D. (2022). Strengthening the 3Rs through advances in evidence integration. ALTEX. Submitted.

Health Canada, 1994. Risk assessment for the combustion products of methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) in gasoline. Health Canada.

Hertzberg, R. C. and Miller, M. A. (1985). A statistical model for species extrapolation using categorical response data. Toxicology and Industrial Health 1, 43-57. doi:10.1177/074823378500100405

King, J. C. and Garza, C. Eds (2007). International harmonisation of approaches for developing nutrient-based dietary standards. Food and Nutrition Bulletin 28, S1-S151.

Krewski, D., Andersen, M. E., Tyshenko, M. G. et al. (2020). Toxicity testing in the 21st century: progress in the past decade and future perspectives. Archives of Toxicology 94, 1-58. doi:10.1007/s00204-019-02613-4

Krewski, D., Chambers, A., Ransom Stern, B. et. al. (2010). Development of a copper database for exposure-response analysis. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health A 73(2), 208-216. doi:10.1080/15287390903340815

Lewis, J. and Dwyer, J. T. (2020). Establishing nutrient intake values. In: Present Knowledge in Nutrition, Volume 2, (B.P. Marriott, D.F. Birt, V.A. Stallings, & A.A. Yates, Eds). Elsevier, London, 267-287. doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-818460-8.01001-7

Magistrato A., Pavlin M., Qasem Z., Ruthstein S. (2019). Copper trafficking in eukaryotic systems: Current knowledge from experimental and rotational efforts. Current Opinion in Structural Biology 58, 26-33. doi:10. 1016/ 2019.05.002

Mattison, D., Milton, B., Krewski, D. et al. (2016). Severity scoring of manganese health effects for categorical regression. Neurotoxicology 58, 203-216. doi:10.1016/j.neuro.2016.09.001

Mertz, W. 1993. Essential trace metals: New definitions based on new paradigms. Nutrition Reviews, 51, 287-295. doi:10.1111/j.1753-4887.1993.tb03057.x

Milton B., Farrell P. J., Birkett N. et al. (2017a). Modeling U-shaped exposure-response relationships for agents that demonstrate toxicity due to both excess and deficiency. Risk Analysis 37, 265-279. doi:10.1111/risa.12603

Milton B., Krewski D., Mattison D. R. et. al. (2017b). Modelling U-shaped dose-response curves for manganese using categorical regression. Neurotoxicology 58, 217-225. doi:10.1016/j.neuro.2016.10.001

NRC – National Research Council, 2000. DRI Dietary Reference Intakes: Applications in Dietary Assessment. National Academies Press, Washington, D.C.

NRC, 2001. Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin A, Vitamin K, Arsenic, Boron, Chromium, Copper, Iodine, Iron, Manganese, Molybdenum, Nickel, Silicon, Vanadium, and Zinc. National Academies Press, Washington, D.C. doi:10.17226/10026

NRC, 2017. Guiding Principles for Developing Dietary Reference Intakes Based on Chronic Disease. National Academies Press, Washington, D.C. doi:10.17226/24828

Ramoju, S. P., Mattison, D. R., Milton, B. et al (2017). The application of PBPK models in estimating human brain tissue manganese concentrations. Neurotoxicology 58, 226-237. doi:10.1016/j.neuro.2016.12.001

Ransom Stern, B., Solioz, M., Krewski, D. et. al. (2007). Copper and human health: Biochemistry, genetics, and strategies for modeling dose-response relationships. A practical approach to microarray data analysis. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health B, Critical Reviews 10(3), 157-222. doi:10.1080/10937400600755911

Renwick A. G., Flynn A, Fletcher R. J., Muller D. J. G., (2004). Risk-benefit analysis of micronutrients. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 42:1903-1922. doi:10.1016/j.fct.2004.07.013

Roels, H. A., Ghyselen, P., Buchet, J. P. et. al. (1992). Assessment of the permissible exposure level to manganese in workers exposed to manganese dioxide dust. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 49(1), 25-34. doi:10.1136/oem.49.1.25

Sand, S., Poirier, C. J. and Krewski, D. (2011). A signal-to-noise crossover dose as the point of departure for health risk assessment. Environmental Health Perspectives 119, 1766-1774. doi:10.1289/ehp.1003327

Sand, S., Parham, F. C. J., Portier, C. J. et al (2017). Comparison of points of departure for health risk assessment based on high-throughput screening data. Environmental Health Perspectives 125, 623-633. doi:10.1289/ehp408

Schroeter, J. D., Nong, A., Yoon, M. et al (2011). Analysis of manganese tracker kinetics and target tissue dosimetry in monkeys and humans with multi-route physiologically-based pharmacokinetic models, Toxicological Sciences, 120(2), 481-498. doi:10.1093/toxsci/kfq389

Smeraldi, C., Giarola, A., Aggett, P. J. et al. (2020). Use of mechanistic information to derive chemical specific adjustment factors - Refinement of risk assessment. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 117, 104776. doi:10.1016/j.yrtph.2020.104776

Strickland, J. A. and Foureman, G. A. (2002). US EPA’s acute reference exposure methodology for acute inhalation exposures. Science of the Total Environment, 288 (April 1-2), 51-63. doi:10.1016/S0048-9697(01)01114-7

Tyshenko, M. G., Willhite, D. Levy, L. et al., 2022. Evolution of the use of toxicological data in evaluating chemical safety. In: Patty’s Toxicology, Seventh Edition (W. Farland & D. Paustenback, Eds). Wiley, New York. To appear.

US EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency), 1993. Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS). 1.B. Reference concentration for chronic inhalation exposure (RfC). US EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) Substance Name: Manganese (CASRN – 7439-96-5).

US EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency), 1994. Re-evaluation of inhalation health risk association with methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) in gasoline. Office of Research and Development, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, Research Triangle Park, NC (EPA 600/R-94/062).

WHO – World Health Organization, 1996. Trace elements in human nutrition and human health. Geneva: World Health Organization.

WHO, 2000. Manganese, Air Quality Guidelines for Europe. 2nd Edition WHO Regional Office for Europe. Copenhagen, Denmark European Series No. 91, 154-156. ISBN 92 890 1358 3.

WHO/IPCS – WHO/International Program on Chemical Safety, 2002. Principles and methods for the assessment of risk from essential trace elements (No. 228), World Health Organization.

WHO, 2006. A model for establishing upper levels of intake for nutrients and related substances. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Technical Workshop on Nutrient Risk Assessment, World Health Organization

Yetley, E. A., MacFarlane, A. J. Greene-Finestone, L. S. et al, 2017. Options for basing Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs) on chronic disease endpoints: report from a joint US/Canadian-sponsored working group. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 105: 249S-285S. doi:10.3945/ajcn.116.139097

Most read articles by the same author(s)